Here is a really interesting exchange I had with someone who had been doing Classical Stretch and then had a minor torn bicep. Read the whole email trail as I find this story fascinating. She wrote to me right before we went to shoot the latest PBS series and the final email is from her a few days ago. It shows that we really have to analyze even the best physiotherapist and keep asking ourselves if what they are doing is helping or not.
Sent: October-18-10 7:27 PM
To: Miranda Esmonde-White
Subject: Need your precious expertise
Hi Miranda,
I really need some special expertise now. I started physio 2 years ago for a torn bicep which is now perfectly healed.
I than told the phiseo about a lower back pain (like a little knife) and some
pain in my inner knees (some pinching).
His diagnosis at the time was that I lacked strength in the inner legs. I was doing your program a lot and he said I was too strong laterally that I had to develop the inside of the legs as well as the flexibility in my spine and my abs. I was jogging also so he stopped me doing your stretching to focus on only working the inner legs, abs and back exercises (the cobra posture). He gave me inner leg strengthening exercises which I have done regularly for almost a year now. Every day I do a series of 30 reps (10-10-10) for legs, abs, arms. As my discomfort increased, I decided to go for MRIs. They found that in both knees I have injured meniscus (intern) and in one knee torn ligaments (lateral & internal). There is also lots of liquid and swelling in both knees. In addition my lower back has developed a hernia L4-L5.
As my knee and back problems worsen I am now walking with a cane. I need your expertise for rehab and pain reduction and a new way of exercising!
The physiotherapist has instructed me to ice and keep doing his exercises for strengthening even with all the pain and inflammation I am suffering. He insists my problems are all about weakness, but it is obvious to me that his exercises worsen my symptoms.
I have no doubt he wants my best interests but I think he has missed something here. I need a more global approach with stretching and enforcement but not in his way.
Can I hire you for the creation of a routine & healing approach? Do you have suggestions?
Thanks very much for your time!
M
On 2010-10-18, at 22:38,
Miranda Esmonde-White wrote:
Dear M
What a terrible story. I am glad that the phiseo helped your torn bicep. But he seems to have been off the mark big time with your knees and back.
I wish I had talked to you when he suggested that you stop doing Classical Stretch. I have never heard of anyone unbalancing their body doing Classical Stretch as it is intended to equally stretch and strengthen the entire body. Ironically your stopping is probably the cause of the major unbalance you are in right now.
I leave to film in Jamaica Wednesday at 4:30 am so I really cannot do anything till I get back November 13th. We should meet Monday November 15th as soon as I get back. I would suggest that you leave the phiseo and try someone else. Until then I would stop any exercising (keep icing) and give your body a rest. And when I get back we can see where you are at and go from there.
I am so sorry to hear about your troubles but I will do my best to help you get better. A cane is not good.
Miranda
Sent: October-19-10 9:11 AM
To: Miranda Esmonde-White
Subject: Re: Need your precious expertise
Dear Miranda
Monday November 15th is perfect! I will stop the phiseo’s exercises and rest and ice. I'm even thinking using crutches for now to relieve my knees from any weight.
By the time you're back I hopefully will have seen a few orthopaedist to evaluate the situation. If you have a good referral for orthopaedist surgeon, I will need someone to better analyze the next steps (removing fluid, reconstructing ligaments, and the meniscus)
Tks a zillion I'm so happy to have emailed you!
M
Sent: November-15-10 4:17 PM
To: Miranda Esmonde-White
Subject: Re: Need your precious expertise
Hi Miranda,
I did your one hour workout while you have been away and my whole condition got 90% better.
I just got a shot of Hyaluronic acid in my right knee and will undergo surgery, ACL reconstruction of left knee which has missed an internal meniscus for 25 years. So I have to be cautious with the knee bending for now but otherwise, there is not much I cannot do.
The operation is for December 16th.
Tks a zillion for bringing health to me and to tons of other injured ladies out there..
M
This is all about a woman’s problem with the alphabet exercise
Sent: July-19-10 7:43 AM
To: Miranda Esmonde-White
Subject: Back pain relief
Miranda,
Thanks so much for the new back pain DVD. I started using it yesterday and it felt good.
I hurt my back several weeks ago while doing the balance exercise, standing on one foot and writing the alphabet. Okay, I thought, have to be more careful. It was only when I pulled the same muscle for the third time that I decided to stop the work-out. At the time I only had the old back pain DVD and it did not help.
Massage and acupuncture worked, but I still kept putting off the workouts. Now there are no more excuses! I will let you know how I get on.
Thanks for all the fabulous work you do. Hope you are well and not working too hard.
K
On 19-Jul-10, at 4:24 PM,
Miranda Esmonde-White wrote:
Hi Kristina,
I am sorry to hear about the alphabet bothering your back. Next time, only do up to the letter D. The alphabet is really a good exercise but obviously your back muscles cannot handle the stress. Try to build to the letter H and then never go beyond that letter, so as to get a sufficient workout without overstressing your back
My best
Miranda
Sent: October-19-10 2:40 PM
To: Miranda Esmonde-White
Subject: Re: Back pain relief
Dear Miranda,
After a long time of doing the Back Pain Relief I am now using the Back to Jamaica DVD’s! I am enjoying it so much and my posture, figure, strength and balance are improving. I was quite desperate during the summer as I thought there was no improvement, but all of a sudden I felt much better. I need a strong back so I can shovel my driveway and sidewalk!
Not only do the exercises make me feel better physically, I am also happier and have more confidence. What a miracle worker you are.
Thanks so much, Miranda.
Best wishes,
K